6 Best Toaster Ovens for Baking and Broiling (Comparison Table)

As you may probably know, baking and broiling are completely different ways to cook food.

Just to make an idea, for baking, the goal is to heat food by surrounding the food with hot air, while in broiling, the cook tries to heat food using infrared radiation.

When you have to cook in the oven, it is very important to be sure that you know the difference between the bake and broil settings; otherwise, you could end up burning your dish.

So, first of all, let’s highlight the difference between baking and broiling.

When baking, the heat is being transferred to the food more or less evenly from all sides. This is why the pre-heating is important: you have to make the air in the appliance interior all the same temperature before the food goes in.

If we talk about broiling, you will need high heat coming from a source very close to the surface of the food. Such a feature is appropriate for thin food, or perhaps, for adding color to already or mostly cooked items.

The baking feature is used for different things like cakes or biscuits.

The broiling feature is perfect for moments when you want to grill a steak, but outside is raining. Your option will be to broil the steak in your oven.

You will have to put the steak in a broiling pan to catch the juice. You should also consider placing the steak very close to the top burner.

If you have understood why it is so important to have an appliance with baking and broiling features, we have selected for you the 6 best toaster ovens for baking and broiling that you should consider if you want to upgrade your kitchen or simply, are looking for a helpful unit in your cooking space.

1. Mueller

1. Mueller MT-175 Toaster Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions

Our list of best toaster ovens for baking and broiling starts with Mueller MT-175 Toaster Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions, an appliance with premium quality components.

It is designed with a special interior for even toasting of up to 4 slices of bread at a time.

You will see that the sleek compact design of the oven gets to fit nicely on any counter-top and at the same time, you have a curved interior with sufficient room for a 9” pizza.

It provides a wide temperature range of 150 to 450 degrees F in order to let you cook with the convenience of an oven, while the natural convection circulates air for faster, even cooking.

This toaster oven can be a great option for everyone as it comes with many features and cooking functions some of which include: baking, broiling, toasting, and keeping food warm. It includes a 30 min timer with precise toast settings and stay-on functionality.

It is delivered with 2 rack positions and an included multi-purpose pan for versatility to have great results for all foods.

With the right appliance, making something to eat is quite simple. And having this oven, you can enjoy lightly browned and bubbly bruschetta or prepare chicken nuggets for the children in minutes.

Forget about heating up the conventional oven as long as you have this trusty machine with four functions that will have you cooking in a hurry.

2. Ninja Foodi

2.1 Ninja Foodi Digital Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions

Choosing Ninja Foodi Digital Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions, you will get the ultimate meal making machine with 8 in 1 functionality.

In this way, you have the possibility to air fry, air roast, air broil, bake, bagel, toast, dehydrate, and keep warm all in one powerful 1800 watt appliance.

With such a unit, you can reclaim your counter space: just consider the fact that this oven takes up 50 % less space when you flip it up and away to store against your backsplash.

At the same time, it provides fast cooking as it gets to cook up to 60 % faster than a traditional oven with air roast.

It is an XL capacity oven with a 45 % larger usable pan cooking area. In case you wonder, you should know that it fits a 13″ pizza, up to 9 slices of toast, or 6 chicken breasts (6 to 8 ounces each).

When air frying, you can use up to 75 % less fat than traditional frying methods and this is tested against hand-cut, deep-fried French fries.

It is the time for you to discover digital crisp control technology; with this technology, you get all you need in terms of precision-controlled temperature, heat source, and airflow for ultimate versatility and optimum cooking performance.

Enjoy toast and bagels done the way you like using the toast darkness selector to get it just right!

3. BLACK+DECKER

3.1 BLACK+DECKER TO3240XSBD Toaster Oven with Bake and Broil Function

We also invite you to discover BLACK+DECKER TO3240XSBD, with an extra-wide interior; in this way, you can be sure that 9”x13” pans with handles, 8 slices of bread or a 12” pizza will fit in your oven.

Considering this thing, you can use the pans you already have as this appliance fits most oven pans.

As you can use whatever pan you want, it means you can go straight from the oven to the table.

It comes with an included baking and broiling pan that fits perfectly, plus a roasting rack is also included. It is so easy to insert and remove food using the included pan. Just remember to remove crumbs from the removable crumb tray before they burn in the bottom of the oven.

This stainless steel/black toaster oven provides 4 cooking functions: baking, broiling, toasting, and keeping food warm.

Forget about waiting around for your large oven in order to get preheated: with this oven, you have to just set the correct temperature and time and you’ll be baking in minutes.

Now, it is so easy to get perfect toast using the dedicated toast timer as this oven provides such a function that allows for predictable shade selection with every use.

It also has a 60-minute precision timer that features stay-on functionality for longer baking tasks. It is true that there is not a specific bagel function, but there is a position on the timing control optimum for bagels.

4. Comfee’

4.1 Comfee’ CFO-CC2501 Toaster Oven Bake and Broil Functions (6 slices)

The design of Comfee’ CFO-CC2501 Toaster Oven Bake and Broil Functions will impress everyone: its compact size is ideal for apartment kitchens, vacation homes, offices, and dorms.

Also, it has a larger interior that can accommodate 6 slices of bread, a 12” pizza, casseroles, cookies, and even a roast.

This oven is easy to operate as it has three dials to control everything.

So, you get the upper dial that controls the temperature, while the middle one controls cooking modes. At the same time, you have a lower dial that features a precise 60-minute timer with stay-on mode allowing for a longer baking time.

As long as this appliance has a stay-on mode perfect for a longer baking time, there will be no issue if you want to get the perfect slice of toast as you have to select the color you prefer.

With a removable crumb tray and non-stick interior surface, this unit can be so easy to clean: both can be cleaned with a damp cloth.

This oven provides a convection fan; its secret is known by everyone as such a fan gets to circulate the hot air within the oven and at the same time, ensures the heat can be delivered to every corner inside the cavity.

Dishes such as chicken nuggets, mozzarella sticks, egg rolls, mini quiches, or whatever you’re craving can be made at home with the right toaster oven.

5.Breville

5. Breville BOV800XL Smart Toast Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions

We also recommend you Breville BOV800XL Smart Toast Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions, known as the smart oven Pro with element iQ.

This is an essential tool for everyone who wants a countertop oven that bakes the perfect pizza, delicious cookies, toasts evenly, and roasts succulent meat.

Despite other models, this toast oven comes with 10 cooking functions to guide you to perfection: Toast 6 slices, Bagel, Bake, Roast, Grill, Pizza, Cookies, Reheat, Warm and Slow Cook.

Also, it provides super-fast 1800 W power in order to preheat and have your meals on the table more quickly.

Everyone who has tried this toaster oven may say that it provides heat, but there is also smart heat.

And this is possible thanks to its element iQ system capable to transfer heat intelligently across 5 quartz elements. And this means precise and stable heat just where and when you want it for perfect results, every time.

It is designed with an LCD Display and in this way, you get more easy access to the built-in smart functionality and for choosing from 10 cooking functions.

Also, the LCD also displays the temperature and cooking time.

And in case you wonder, the oven has an integrated oven light that automatically turns on when you open the door and at the end of the cooking, cycle to help you see inside and also, for more safety, an auto shut off and independently controlled button.

6. Hamilton Beach

6. Hamilton Beach 31156 Countertop Toaster Oven with Bake and Broil Functions

Last but not least, we invite you to meet Hamilton Beach 31156 Countertop Toaster Oven with Bake and Broil Functions, a 2 in 1 combination that ensures you that you are going to do more in less space with this countertop oven.

Just think of the fact that you can bake, broil, and toast by easily switching cooking modes with the slide of a lever.

If you want to be fast when cooking, consider the fact that the 2 in 1 toaster oven toasts bread 40 percent faster than the leading toaster oven. In this way, you can get your sliced bread warm and crispy, quick.

Do not worry about the interior: it provides a spacious interior and you can cook whatever you like.

It has 2 rack positions and in its large interior, it fits a 9-inch pizza and at the same time, it is perfect for making muffins, baked potatoes, casseroles, and more.

With a separate shade selector, this toaster oven gives you more control when toasting; now, it is possible to reach the perfect level of golden brown toast.

The 60-minute timer with auto-shutoff ensures you peace of mind as all you have to do is to set the toaster oven timer up to 60 minutes and enjoy your time with the rest of the family until the food is ready.

It is a safe unit as it provides an auto-shutoff feature that turns the oven off when baking time is reached.

Whatever you think about a morning breakfast rush or busy weeknight dinner, you can be sure that there’s no need to worry about overcooking or leaving the oven on if you have set the timer.

7. Comparison Table

Brand	Mueller Austria	Ninja	Spectrum Brands	COMFEE’	Breville	Hamilton Beach
Model	Mueller MT-175 Toaster Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions	Ninja Foodi Digital Oven with Baking and Broiling Functions	BLACK+DECKER TO3240XSBD	Comfee’ CFO-CC2501 Toaster Oven Bake and Broil Functions (6   slices)	Breville BOV800XL Smart Toast Oven with Baking and Broiling   Functions	Hamilton Beach 31156 Countertop Toaster Oven with Bake and Broil   Functions
Color	Gray	a Stainless Steel Finish	Stainless Steel/Black	Black	Silver	Stainless steel
Power	1100 watts of power	1800 watt	1500 watts	1500 Watts	1800-watt toaster	1450 watts
Voltage	120 volts AC	120 volts at 60 hz	120 volts, 60 hertz, and 12.5 amps	120V	110 to 120 Volts	It is designed to work with 120V, 60 Hz AC power source
Warranty	Mueller USA’s 2 year no-hassle replacement policy	1 year limited warranty when purchased from an authorized   retailer of SharkNinja Operating LLC	Two year limited warranty for any defect in material or   workmanship	1 year warranty	1 year limited product warranty	1 year limited warranty in the US, and 5 years in Canada
Temp Range and step	Wide temperature range of 150 to 450 degrees F	between 105°F and 450°F,	The lowest temperature setting is 150° (F), maximum temperature   of 450 F	150°F – 450°F	120 to 500 degrees F	Oven temp goes up to 450 then broil
Timer (min-max and step)	The 30 min timer includes precise toast settings and stay-on   functionality	This system allows you to set the timer for up to 12 hours	This toaster oven has a timer that turns it off when timer is   done	60-min timer	an electronic timer that functions like that of a microwave	60 minute timer with auto shutoff
Auto shut Off Timer	when you set the timer to toast it shuts itself off when the   timer goes off	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes, the auto shutoff turns the oven off when baking time is   reached
Interior Dimensions	From side to side = 14.5 inches, Front to back = 12.5 inches, and   the height = 9.5 inches	13″ x 13″ x 3″	12”deep x 16”Length	10 inches across, 9 inches deep, 6 inches tall	(W) 13¼ x (D) 11¼ x (H) 5¼	H 4″, L 12″, W 9″
Exterior Dimensions	16.9 x 14.1 x 11.5 inches	overall depth is 15 inches width is 20 inches	5.75 x 24.45 x 13.7 inches	19″ X 15.6″ X 10.8″	(W) 15¾ x (D) 18½x (H) 11	12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 inches
Non Stick Interior (Yes/No)	The inside is just shiny metal, there is no nonstick in this   toaster	The interior is coated its stainless steel on the outside	No	non-stick interior	Yes	It does not have a non-stick coating
Interior Material	Interior material is stainless steel	stainless steel	The interior is aluminum	Metal	Stainless steel	Stainless steel
Capacity: toast bread slices	It fits 4 slices of bread	up to 9 slices of toast	eight pieces of bread	4 or 6 slices	6-slice toast capacity	you can put toast to 6 slices comfortably
Interior Light (Yes/No)	No	there is a light that comes on right before the time is over and   it can be turned on during cooking.	This oven is not equipped with an interior light	This toaster does not have an interior light	This one does not have a light	No oven light
Weight	2.2 pounds	15.72 pounds	16.27 pounds	16.46 pounds	22 pounds	14.78 pounds
Rack Positions (1, 2,3,4)	2 rack positions	2 rack positions	2 rack positions	two rack adjustments	3 rack positions	2 rack positions
Functions
Auto shut Off	No	No	it has an automatic shut off as well as a ‘stay on’ option	No	No	No
Air Fry	No	Yes	No	No	No	No
Bake	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Broil	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Warm	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No
Toast	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Includes
Oven Rack	1 baking rack	No, an air fry basket	No	baking rack	magnetic auto-eject rack	a top rack
Pan	1 baking pan	Yes	a broiler pan	baking pan	a broiler pan and and a pizza pan	Yes
Does this get really hot around the oven?	Yes, the outside does get hot	Yes, it get hot on the outside	It does get pretty warm.	It gets very hot	it gets hot	The top gets warm, but not hot enough to burn you
Cleaning	The bottom opens for easy cleaning	Easy cleaning: Includes a removable crumb tray and an easily   accessible back panel for deep cleaning	The inner cavity of this toaster oven can only be cleaned with   soap and water	it is fairly easy to clean	Wipe off nonstick surface make cleaning a breeze	very nice and very easy to clean
Noise	Not very loud	a soft fan noise	no loud noise	not overly loud	very low noise level	it’s quite noisy
Racks and tray Dishwasher Safe	crumb tray dishwasher safe	sheet pan and air fry basket are dishwasher safe	No	N/A	the pans and wire rack are dishwasher safe	No
Cord length	2 prong polarized cord	3 ft.	about 3 feet long	approximately 3 feet	3 feet long	slightly over 2 feet long (26 or 27 inches)